The Digital Transformation: Analysis of Restructuring Trends in the European Union’s Retail Banking Sector

The retail banking sector within the European Union (EU) is undergoing a significant transformation, primarily driven by the rapid digitalisation of financial services. This sector, which has been a cornerstone of the EU’s economy, is now at the forefront of a digital revolution that is reshaping the way financial services are delivered and consumed.

This article provides an insightful analysis of the restructuring trends in the EU’s retail banking sector, exploring the implications of digitalisation on employment, work organisation, and the future trajectory of the sector.

The Evolution of Retail Banking Employment

Over the past decade, the employment landscape in the EU’s retail banking sector has undergone a noticeable shift. While most service sectors have experienced job growth, employment in retail banking has been on a downward trajectory. This decline was initially triggered by the financial crisis, which led to a significant contraction in the sector. However, in recent years, the advent of digitalisation and the transition to online retail banking have further accelerated this trend.

In parallel with the decline in employment, the physical infrastructure of retail banking has also seen a reduction. The number of bank branches per 100,000 inhabitants in the EU has dropped from around 30 in 2004 to approximately 20 in recent years. This trend underscores the growing preference for online banking services among consumers and the corresponding shift in banks’ operational strategies.

The Role of Social Dialogue in Managing Restructuring

The restructuring processes in the retail banking sector are often large in scale, lengthy, and complex compared to other sectors. These processes are managed through well-established institutional frameworks of social dialogue, which benefit from high levels of representation and collective organisation. Social dialogue plays a crucial role in mitigating the negative effects of restructuring, ensuring that the interests of employees are adequately represented and their rights protected during the transition.

The Emergence of Specialised Professionals

The digital transformation of retail banking has led to a significant change in the sector’s employment composition. There has been a rapid increase in the share of specialised professionals, with two-thirds of those in retail banking in the EU now holding third-level qualifications. This trend reflects the growing demand for high-skilled jobs such as legal experts, data scientists, and network security experts, which are critical to supporting the digital operations of banks.

To meet this growing demand and to enhance the employability of those in more traditional banking roles, the sector needs to develop targeted skills policies. These policies should focus on upskilling and reskilling employees, equipping them with the necessary skills to navigate the digital landscape.

The Transformation of Work in Retail Banking

Digitalisation has fundamentally altered the nature of work in retail banking. There has been a marked increase in the number of ‘computer-facing’ jobs, which involve working with digital platforms and tools, and a corresponding decrease in customer-facing roles. This shift reflects the sector’s changing dynamics of service delivery, with more customers opting for online banking services.

The sector has also seen a significant rise in teleworking, particularly during the pandemic. The large share of ‘teleworkable’ jobs in retail banking has enabled the sector to adapt to the new working conditions imposed by the pandemic, with nearly one in two financial sector workers in the EU working remotely either ‘usually’ or ‘sometimes’ in 2021.

Addressing the Gender Pay Gap in Retail Banking

Despite being a high-paying sector, retail banking reports the highest gender pay gap among all sectors in the EU. This gap is partly due to the over-representation of men in higher-paying IT-related occupations and supervisory and managerial roles. However, the proposed EU Pay Transparency directive, which foresees gender pay audits, is expected to be crucial in identifying and addressing other factors contributing to the sector’s high gender pay gap.

Conclusion: Navigating the Future of Retail Banking in the EU

The retail banking sector in the EU is at a pivotal point in its history. The digital revolution is reshaping the sector’s operational and employment landscape, bringing about profound changes that will define its future trajectory. As the sector navigates these changes, it is confronted with a range of challenges and opportunities that require careful consideration and strategic action.

The ongoing restructuring processes, driven by digitalisation, increased regulatory and compliance burden, competition from fintech, and low-interest rates, have significant implications for the sector. These changes are not only transforming the way banks operate but are also reshaping the nature of employment in the sector. The shift towards online banking services has led to a decline in traditional, customer-facing roles and a rise in ‘computer-facing’ jobs. This shift necessitates a rethinking of skills policies in the sector, with a focus on upskilling and reskilling employees to equip them with the necessary digital skills.

The restructuring processes also underscore the importance of social dialogue in managing transitions. As banks undergo restructuring, it is crucial to ensure that the interests of employees are adequately represented and their rights protected. The established frameworks of social dialogue in the sector provide a robust mechanism for managing these transitions, highlighting the importance of collective organisation and representation in mitigating the negative effects of restructuring.

However, as the sector navigates these changes, it must also address the persistent issue of the gender pay gap. Despite being a high-paying sector, retail banking reports the highest gender pay gap among all sectors in the EU. This gap is a reflection of the broader societal and structural inequalities that persist in the labour market. Addressing this gap requires concerted efforts at multiple levels, from promoting gender diversity in high-paying IT-related and managerial roles to implementing pay transparency measures.

Looking ahead, the retail banking sector in the EU faces a future that is both challenging and promising. The digital revolution presents opportunities for banks to innovate and improve their services, but it also brings challenges that require strategic adaptation. As the sector continues to evolve, it will be crucial to ensure that the benefits of digitalisation are shared equitably among all stakeholders, from employees to customers. This will require a commitment to social dialogue, investment in skills development, and a concerted effort to address gender inequalities.

In conclusion, the future of retail banking in the EU will be defined by its ability to navigate the digital revolution, manage restructuring processes effectively, and address the challenges of skills development and gender inequality. As the sector embarks on this journey, it has the opportunity to shape a future that is not only economically sustainable but also socially inclusive.

Richard Kelley

“Certified food guru. Internet maven. Bacon junkie. Tv enthusiast. Avid writer. Gamer. Beeraholic.”